法律教育網

法律英語

2019瑞達法考客觀題學習包

考試內容 報名條件 報名時間 報名方法

成績查詢 考試時間 分 數 線 授予資格

您的位置:法律教育網 > 法律英語 > 經典案例 > 正文

Conspiracy of silence allowed NHS rape spree

2016-02-15 11:41  來源:   糾錯

IT WAS a secret that William Kerr was determined to cover up. Working as a National Health Service psychiatrist in Northern Ireland he had been accused of luring a teenage patient into his car, claiming that sex would help her mental condition. After an internal inquiry the Belfast hospital advised him that “if he wanted to continue to practise medicine” he should leave Northern Ireland. He applied to Clifton hospital in York but omitted the references from his Belfast job in his CV.

The fact that Clifton neither spotted this nor even telephoned his previous employers to check his bona fides allowed him to continue where he had left off — preying on young, mentally unstable women.

It was a laxity within the NHS that was to continue from his appointment in 1965 until his retirement in 1988. A government inquiry has now concluded that during this time he raped or sexually molested at least 67 women.

The inquiry — set up after an investigation into the allegations by The Sunday Times — blames an “institutional moral failure” in the NHS for allowing him to get away with it for so long. It said that junior staff were unwilling to question “all-powerful” consultants and that complaints by patients were ignored.

The inquiry concluded that the scandal was not investigated for 20 years because of excessive respect for and fear of consultants; a greater concern for professionals than for patients; an exaggerated loyalty to colleagues and a tendency to disbelieve mentally ill patients.

Kerr, an arrogant, bullying figure, was persistently alleged to have made sexual advances towards women and was described by staff as a “ladies' man” and a “flirt”。 He used his power as a consultant to silence his victims. In the report a patient claims that Kerr told her: “In the state you are in, who would believe you? Would they believe you or me?” Thirty-eight of his female patients made complaints to nurses and 11 GPs but they were largely dismissed as fantasists or troublemakers. Only one GP, Dr John Wade, approached a senior figure. He turned to Michael Haslam, also a consultant psychiatrist at Clifton hospital and who, unknown to Wade, was sexually assaulting his own patients.

According to the inquiry, Haslam molested at least 10 of his patients, using his psycho-sexual disorder clinic to practise a range of treatments unheard of by other psychiatrists. These included full-body massages, carbon dioxide inhalation therapy and “kirlian” photography aimed at identifying patients' aura — which usually took place in a darkened room.

Kathy Haq, a senior nurse who was herself sexually assaulted by Kerr, said: “There was the most incredible conspiracy of silence and apathy. It was an old boys' network where they buried their heads in the sand and convinced themselves that despite the numbers of patients involved, we were all neurotic women.”

Ruth Payne of Ripon, another former patient who was molested by Kerr, said: “We have been shocked and very angry at the number of health authority staff who knew what Kerr and Haslam were doing to patients and failed to stop them. I hope they have learnt a very hard lesson.”

Kerr's years of abuse remained secret even after his retirement in 1988. It was not until February 1997 that one of his patients walked into Harrogate police station and accused Kerr of raping her and forcing her to have oral sex between 1983 and 1986. He was charged but was judged unfit to stand trial for health reasons.

As early as 1988 Haslam was advised by a senior colleague to “consider retirement” after allegations of rape and sexual assault by a patient. However, no investigation was launched and in 1989 he was promoted to become medical director of Harrogate clinic.

It was not until 1996, when two patients complained to the General Medical Council, that action began to be taken against Haslam, who was by then medical director of South Durham NHS Trust.

Malcolm Timperley, a consultant psychiatrist in Scarborough who helped one of the patients to make her complaint, said: “I was furious that nobody seemed to be interested in what was going on. It did seem to be a conspiracy. Every time I mentioned it, people in the higher ranks of the medical establishment warned me off and said it wouldn't do me any good to go poking my nose in.”

Even then, according to the government inquiry, Haslam might never have been prosecuted if he had not sued The Sunday Times for libel after the newspaper revealed details of the allegations against him.

Although the regional health authority launched an inquiry into Haslam's activities in 1997, it was evidence gathered by this newspaper to defend the libel that put Haslam in the dock on four counts of indecent assault and one charge of rape. He was given a seven-year sentence but on appeal the rape charge was quashed and his sentence reduced to three years.

Haslam said he was appealing against his conviction to the Criminal Cases Review Commission. He remained defiant, saying: “For £3.2m this inquiry has established that a defunct health trust 25 years ago didn't handle complaints very well.”

Kerr could not be reached for comment.

Haslam's conviction is small solace for Linda Bigwood, a deputy nursing sister who did the most to try to alert the authorities during the 1980s. She was demoted and warned that she faced the sack for her dogged campaign against Kerr. She left the profession and returned only in the late 1990s when criminal proceedings were launched against Kerr. “My career was destroyed by a campaign of lies about me and I have had to completely rebuild it,” she said. “It grieves me that Kerr, the more serious offender, is still a free man.”

Tomorrow Bigwood, 49, will start work in the first senior management job commensurate with her skills since her career was threatened by her efforts to expose Kerr's and then Haslam's sexual assaults.

Lila Taylor, who was indecently assaulted by Haslam, said she was “very pleased” with the inquiry report, which makes 70 recommendations to ensure that staff report and record allegations by patients and that references are checked.

No new NHS appointment should be made, it states, unless references from a candidate's three most recent employers are taken up. If this had been done in 1965, Kerr's reign of abuse could have been prevented.

責任編輯:儀

特別推薦

地圖
法律教育網官方微信

法律教育網微信公眾號向您推薦考試資訊、輔導資料、考試教材、歷年真題、法律常識、法律法規等資訊,只有你想不到,沒有我們做不到!詳情>>

1、凡本網注明“來源:法律教育網”的所有作品,版權均屬法律教育網所有,未經本網授權不得轉載、鏈接、轉貼或以其他方式使用;已經本網授權的,應在授權范圍內使用,且必須注明“來源:法律教育網”。違反上述聲明者,本網將追究其法律責任。

2、本網部分資料為網上搜集轉載,均盡力標明作者和出處。對于本網刊載作品涉及版權等問題的,請作者與本網站聯系,本網站核實確認后會盡快予以處理。

本網轉載之作品,并不意味著認同該作品的觀點或真實性。如其他媒體、網站或個人轉載使用,請與著作權人聯系,并自負法律責任。

3、本網站歡迎積極投稿

湖北武汉| 天水| 开封| 梅州| 株洲| 眉山| 甘肃兰州| 晋中| 鄂州| 宁波| 凉山| 芜湖| 甘南| 桐乡| 永康| 南安| 辽宁沈阳| 驻马店| 攀枝花| 马鞍山| 中山| 清远| 顺德| 漳州| 平潭| 香港香港| 库尔勒| 内蒙古呼和浩特| 肥城| 博罗| 内蒙古呼和浩特| 仁怀| 淮安| 周口| 南阳| 五指山| 明港| 黄山| 中山| 张家界| 神木| 海宁| 德宏| 南阳| 张家界| 朔州| 改则| 张家口| 姜堰| 大连| 燕郊| 新泰| 凉山| 桓台| 黔南| 博罗| 高雄| 绵阳| 中山| 定安| 宿迁| 牡丹江| 石嘴山| 凉山| 青海西宁| 中山| 东方| 邯郸| 海东| 邳州| 临夏| 莱州| 海拉尔| 鄢陵| 喀什| 黑龙江哈尔滨| 惠州| 陇南| 包头| 五家渠| 青海西宁| 广州| 平凉| 日喀则| 绥化| 灵宝| 惠州| 新乡| 张北| 昭通| 塔城| 广西南宁| 佛山| 安康| 铜仁| 陕西西安| 姜堰| 眉山| 滨州| 迪庆| 临海| 北海| 邯郸| 贵州贵阳| 邹城| 呼伦贝尔| 澳门澳门| 崇左| 昌吉| 吴忠| 桂林| 屯昌| 眉山| 垦利| 菏泽| 聊城| 甘南| 兴安盟| 海宁| 和县| 衡水| 雄安新区| 锦州| 桂林| 宁德| 承德| 明港| 海门| 喀什| 瑞安| 沧州| 山南| 沧州| 北海| 海拉尔| 黄山| 内蒙古呼和浩特| 茂名| 佛山| 沛县| 钦州| 安庆| 阳春| 吐鲁番| 防城港| 大同| 榆林| 昌吉| 永新| 秦皇岛| 舟山| 辽源| 海西| 淮安| 汕头| 汝州| 台中| 莒县| 陕西西安| 临沂| 肇庆| 儋州| 芜湖| 三沙| 台中| 驻马店| 灌南| 景德镇| 锡林郭勒| 台南| 定西| 迁安市| 巴音郭楞| 防城港| 广饶| 三门峡| 保山| 济宁| 濮阳| 杞县| 陕西西安| 淮安| 五家渠| 商洛| 阳江| 宜昌| 通辽| 唐山| 中卫| 苍南| 台州| 阜新| 宁德| 南京| 淮安| 如皋| 新乡| 沭阳| 河源| 济南| 曹县| 阿坝| 衢州| 新余| 澳门澳门| 宝应县| 淮安| 沭阳| 三沙| 云南昆明| 澄迈| 吐鲁番| 黑河| 淮北| 达州| 新泰| 商洛| 宁波| 潮州| 安阳| 章丘| 东台| 义乌| 昌吉| 云浮| 桐乡| 珠海| 莱州| 蓬莱| 株洲| 武夷山| 高密| 河池| 滨州| 聊城| 湛江| 莆田| 克孜勒苏| 莱芜| 单县| 广汉| 宜昌| 广汉| 百色| 昭通| 涿州| 漳州| 汕头| 长葛| 丹阳| 日土| 宝应县| 铜川| 白沙| 乌兰察布| 汝州| 涿州| 白城| 通辽| 临汾| 烟台| 广西南宁| 潍坊| 蓬莱| 昌吉| 辽宁沈阳| 马鞍山| 四平| 甘南| 诸暨| 阜新| 淮安| 灌南| 永康| 石嘴山| 铜川| 随州| 黄石| 鹰潭| 顺德| 锦州| 漯河| 单县| 浙江杭州| 烟台| 博尔塔拉| 乌海| 扬中| 凉山| 邹平| 上饶| 杞县| 台南| 伊犁| 和县| 大丰| 百色| 临沧| 香港香港| 湖州|